Skip to main content

Aparna Rollform

Difference Between Perforated and Ladder Type Cable Tray

perforated cable tray vs ladder type

The main difference between perforated and ladder type cable tray is how the cables are supported. A perforated cable tray has a continuous slotted base, so it supports cables along their full length. A ladder type cable tray has two side rails joined by rungs, so cables rest only on the rungs, with open space for air between them.

In practice, perforated trays suit smaller control, instrumentation and data cables that need continuous support. Ladder trays suit large power cables, longer spans between supports and routes where maximum airflow matters. Many projects use both.

This guide compares the two types side by side, explains each difference in plain terms, and ends with a checklist for choosing between them.

Perforated Cable Tray vs Ladder Type: At a Glance

The table below compares the two types on the points that usually decide the choice.

FactorPerforated cable trayLadder type cable tray
ConstructionOne formed steel sheet: a slotted base with side flangesTwo side rails (runners) joined by rungs at regular intervals
How cables are supportedContinuously, along the full lengthOnly at each rung
VentilationGood: air passes through the slotsBetter: the base is almost entirely open
Best-suited cablesSmall and medium cables: control, instrumentation, data, lightingLarge power cables and heavy cable bundles
Support spanOften used where supports are closer togetherOften chosen where supports are further apart
Cable exitsThrough a drop-out fitting or an opening cut in the trayBetween any two rungs
Dust and waterWater drains through the slots; dust can settle on the baseDust and water fall through
Protection from belowSome, from the continuous baseVery little
Typical usesCommercial buildings, control rooms, instrumentation routes, IT areasPower plants, substations, heavy industry, outdoor pipe racks, vertical risers
CoversAvailableAvailable

What Is a Perforated Cable Tray?

A perforated cable tray is a cable tray with a solid steel base punched with rows of slots, and side flanges formed from the same sheet. The cables lie on the base, which supports them continuously along the run. The slots let air and water pass through and give convenient points for tying cables down.

Because the base supports the cable at every point, small or flexible cables do not droop. This is why perforated trays are the usual choice for control, instrumentation, data and lighting circuits, and for neat, visible runs in commercial buildings. For more on standards and uses, see perforated cable trays in electrical projects.

What Is a Ladder Type Cable Tray?

A ladder type cable tray, also called a cable ladder, consists of two longitudinal side rails (called runners) joined by transverse rungs at regular intervals. Cables rest on the rungs, and the gaps between rungs leave the underside of the cables open to the air.

The deep side rails carry the load between supports, which makes ladder trays well suited to heavy power cables and long spans. The open design also makes it easy to lay cables in, tie them to the rungs and bring them out anywhere along the run. See why ladder trays suit heavy, long-span cable runs.

Key Differences Between Perforated and Ladder Type Cable Trays

Cable Support: Continuous Base vs Rungs

This is the difference behind most of the others. On a perforated tray, the base supports the cable at every point. On a ladder tray, the cable spans from one rung to the next.

Large power cables are stiff enough to bridge that gap without trouble. Small cables are not. A thin control or data cable laid across rungs spaced a few hundred millimetres apart can sag between them. If a route carries mostly small cables, a perforated tray avoids the problem.

Ventilation and Heat Dissipation

Ladder trays give better airflow. Their base is almost entirely open, so heat from the cables escapes from above and below. Perforated trays also ventilate well through their slots, but part of the base is solid steel, so less air reaches the underside of the cables.

Airflow matters most for heavily loaded power cables, because a cable that runs hotter must be derated, meaning it can carry less current. For cable sizing, IEC 60364-5-52 lists cables on a perforated tray and cables on a ladder as separate installation types. The designer should use the factors for the tray type actually installed.

Some comparisons online rate perforated trays as better ventilated than ladder trays. For the same cables and layout, the more open ladder design allows more airflow.

Load Capacity and Support Span

Ladder trays are generally chosen for heavy cable loads and for longer spans between supports, because their deep side rails work like beams. This is where the common rule “ladder for heavy cables, perforated for light cables” comes from.

Treat that rule as a starting point, not a specification. The load any tray can safely carry depends on its side height, steel thickness and the distance between supports, whichever type it is. So don’t compare a deep perforated tray and a shallow ladder tray on type alone.

Before choosing, ask the manufacturer for the safe working load (SWL) at the support span shown on your drawings. IEC 61537 sets out the SWL test for both cable trays and cable ladders.

Cable Access, Exits and Future Changes

On a ladder tray, cables can drop out between any two rungs, and you can tie them directly to the rungs. This makes additions and re-routing simple. On a perforated tray, cables usually leave through a drop-out fitting or an opening cut in the base or side, with cable ties passing through the slots.

Both are open trays, so you can lay new cables in from above on either type without pulling them through.

Dust, Water and Protection

Dust and water fall straight through a ladder tray. On a perforated tray, the slots let water drain, but dust can settle on the solid parts of the base. This is worth considering in dusty areas.

In return, the continuous base of a perforated tray gives cables some protection from below. Neither type is an enclosure. Where cables need protection from falling objects or direct sun, fit cable tray covers, which are available for both types.

Finish and Corrosion

Manufacturers offer both types in the same finishes, so the site environment, not the tray type, should decide the coating. As a general guide:

  • Pre-galvanised (GI) steel for dry, indoor areas
  • Hot-dip galvanised steel for outdoor, humid and industrial sites
  • Stainless steel, or aluminium where suitable, for corrosive environments such as chemical plants and coastal sites

One check applies to each type. On a perforated tray, the slot edges are cut surfaces. On a ladder tray with welded rungs, the welds are exposed steel. Ask whether the tray is galvanised after punching and welding, or how these edges and welds are protected. This guide to the cable tray manufacturing process explains the difference between pre-galvanised and hot-dip galvanised trays.

Cost

There is no fixed rule on which type costs less. Price depends on width, height, thickness, finish and quantity. The tray is also only part of the installed cost: supports, fittings and labour count too. To compare fairly, get quotations for the same width, finish and support span.

Where Each Type Is Used?

These are typical uses. The final choice still depends on the cables on each route.

Perforated Cable Tray Applications

  • Control, instrumentation and signal cables in process plants
  • Lighting and small power circuits in offices, hospitals, malls and other commercial buildings
  • Data and communication cables in control rooms and IT areas
  • Branch runs from a main cable route to individual equipment

Ladder Type Cable Tray Applications

  • Main power cable routes in power plants, substations and heavy industry
  • Feeder cables from transformers and switchgear
  • Long runs on outdoor pipe racks and structures
  • Vertical risers in high-rise buildings and industrial plants

Using Both Types in One Project

Many projects use both. A common arrangement puts main power routes and risers on ladder trays, and control and instrumentation cables and branch runs on perforated trays. Keeping power and control cables on separate trays also makes it easier to segregate them. For data centre layouts, see cable trays in data centres.

How to Choose Between Perforated and Ladder Type Cable Trays?

Work through these questions for each cable route:

  1. What cables will it carry? Mostly large power cables point to a ladder tray. Mostly small control, instrumentation or data cables point to a perforated tray.
  2. How much heat will the cables produce? Heavily loaded power circuits benefit from the open base of a ladder tray.
  3. How far apart are the supports? Longer spans usually point to a ladder tray. For either type, confirm the safe working load at your support span.
  4. What is the environment? Dusty or wet areas favour the open ladder design. Where cables need some protection from below, a perforated tray helps. Add covers where needed.
  5. How often will cables be added or changed? Frequent additions and exits are easier on a ladder tray.
  6. Will the tray be visible? In offices and public areas, a perforated tray gives a neater look.

In short: choose a ladder type cable tray for heavy power cables, long spans and maximum airflow. Choose a perforated cable tray for smaller cables that need continuous support. For either, confirm the safe working load at your support span.

When Neither Type Is the Right Choice?

Perforated and ladder trays are both open supports. If cables need a more enclosed route, for example against falling debris, consider solid bottom cable trays with covers, or raceways.

Aparna Rollform Perforated and Ladder Type Cable Trays

Aparna Rollform, the roll-forming division of Aparna Enterprises Limited, manufactures both perforated and ladder type cable trays at its plant in Patancheru, Telangana. The main parameters of each are below.

ParameterPerforated cable trayLadder type cable tray
Width50 mm to 1,500 mm50 mm to 1,500 mm
HeightSide heights from 25 mm to 120 mmRunner heights from 50 mm to 120 mm
Collar15 mm to 45 mm15 mm to 25 mm
Thickness1.6 mm to 3.0 mm1.6 mm to 3.0 mm (runners and rungs)
Length2,500 mm to 6,000 mm2,500 mm and 3,000 mm
BaseContinuous base with 20 × 10 mm slotsRungs from 30 × 15 mm to 50 × 20 mm, spaced 250 mm to 300 mm centre to centre, supplied welded or bolt-fitted
Material and finishMild steel, either pre-galvanised (GI sheet, 80–120 GSM total for both sides, to IS 277) or hot-dip galvanised after fabrication (minimum 420 GSM per side, to IS 2629, IS 2633, IS 4759 and IS 6745), or powder-coated. Also made in aluminium and stainless steelThe same materials and finishes, plus painted

Aparna Rollform’s hot-dip galvanised trays are made from mild-steel sheet and galvanised as the last step, after cutting, punching, welding and grinding, so the slot edges and welds are coated along with the rest of the tray.

For demanding sites such as oil and gas and marine installations, Aparna Rollform also makes angular ladder trays. These use mild-steel angle runners from 25 × 25 × 3 mm to 100 × 100 × 6 mm, 3.0 mm and above thick. For both tray types, Aparna Rollform also makes hut, flat and U-type covers across the full width range: in a single sheet up to 1,200 mm wide, and in two parts from 1,200 mm to 1,500 mm. It also makes bends, tees, crosses and reducers.

Aparna Enterprises Limited (Rollform Division) holds ISO 9001:2015, ISO 14001:2015 and ISO 45001:2018 certification. Aparna Rollform supplies all its trays from Hyderabad.

Not sure which type suits your project? Share your cable schedule, support spacing and site conditions with the Aparna Rollform team for a recommendation on tray type, size and finish. You can also browse all the cable tray types we manufacture.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a cable ladder and a cable tray?

A cable ladder is the same product as a ladder type cable tray. IEC 61537, the international standard for these systems, treats them as two families. A cable tray has a base with side members, while a cable ladder has side members joined by rungs. In India, both are usually called cable trays, with the type named in front.

Yes, but small or flexible cables can sag between the rungs. For routes that carry mostly small control, instrumentation or data cables, a perforated cable tray gives continuous support. On a mixed route, small cables are often run on a separate perforated tray.

Yes, and it is common. Ladder trays usually carry the main power routes and risers, while perforated trays carry control and instrumentation cables and branch runs. Plan where one type changes to the other, so that the change is supported and electrically bonded.

You can use both types outdoors if the finish suits the site. Ladder trays are common on outdoor pipe racks because dust and water fall through. Hot-dip galvanised steel is the usual outdoor finish, and covers help protect cables from direct sun and falling objects.

There is no fixed rule on which type costs less. Price depends on width, height, thickness, finish and quantity, and supports, fittings and labour add to the installed cost. To compare fairly, get quotations for the same width, finish and support span.

IEC 61537, “Cable management – Cable tray systems and cable ladder systems”, covers both perforated trays and ladders. It sets out the test for a tray’s safe working load (SWL), so ask for SWL figures tested to IEC 61537 at your support span.

Related Blogs